Homemade Pecan Butter

Homemade pecan butter is rich, naturally sweet, and deeply nutty, with a flavor that becomes even more fragrant when the pecans are lightly roasted. Made with just pecans, cinnamon, and a pinch of salt, this simple nut butter needs no added oil or sweetener. Of all the nut butters I’ve tried, pecan butter remains my favorite — and I’m still surprised it doesn’t receive more attention.

Discovering pecan butter in Texas

When I first discovered pecan butter, Georgia Grinders was the only brand I could find in the United States — and even that was difficult to track down. I was immediately impressed by its rich, buttery flavor and natural sweetness. It tasted completely different from the other nut butters I knew.

What surprised me most was that hardly anyone seemed to be talking about it, especially in Texas, where pecan trees are native and fresh pecans are abundant.

For a long time, I assumed pecan butter was better known than it actually was. Then, one weekend at the Dallas Farmers Market, I bought fresh Texas pecans directly from a farmer. When I mentioned how much I loved pecan butter, he looked surprised. He had never tried it and asked me how to make it.

That conversation convinced me it was time to share this very simple recipe.

What does pecan butter taste like?

Pecan butter is rich, buttery, and slightly sweet, even without added sugar. Compared with almond butter, it has a warmer, more distinctive flavor and an almost dessert-like quality.

Before moving to the United States, peanut butter was the only nut butter I really knew. It wasn’t common in Romania when I was growing up, and I had to learn to appreciate it. Pecan butter was an entirely different experience: I loved it immediately.

Technically, peanuts are legumes rather than nuts. Pecans offer a flavorful alternative for anyone who avoids peanuts or simply wants to explore other nut butters.

Do pecans contain lectins?

Pecans are included on the Plant Paradox–approved food list and are one of the nuts I regularly use in my lectin-free recipes.

Other options include walnuts, pistachios, macadamia nuts, Brazil nuts, hazelnuts, barùkas, and blanched almonds without their skins. As with any food, individual tolerance can vary, especially for people with nut sensitivities or allergies.

Why the pecans should be roasted

Lightly roasting the pecans is the key to making flavorful pecan butter. The heat intensifies their natural sweetness, deepens their nutty flavor, and helps release their oils during processing.

Pecans can burn quickly, so keep a close eye on them. They need only 7 to 10 minutes at 300°F (150°C), until fragrant and slightly deeper in color. If they roast for too long, they can become bitter.

Let the pecans cool before processing them.

What equipment do you need?

A sturdy food processor or high-speed blender makes homemade nut butter much easier. The final texture will depend on the power of your appliance and how long you process the pecans.

A food processor may produce a slightly textured butter, while a high-speed blender designed to work without added liquid can create a smoother consistency. Personally, I don’t mind a little texture.

Process the pecans until they release their oils and transform from finely ground nuts into a creamy butter. Stop occasionally to scrape down the sides, and allow the appliance to rest if the motor becomes too warm.

TIP: One reader also suggested transferring the processed pecan butter to a Nutribullet for a final blend if you prefer an especially smooth consistency. And I think this is genius!

Cinnamon, salt, and optional additions

Pecan butter is delicious with nothing more than a pinch of good-quality salt. I also like to add cinnamon, which complements the warm, naturally sweet flavor of the toasted pecans.

Some recipes add maple syrup or another sweetener, but I don’t find it necessary. Pecans already have a subtle sweetness, especially after roasting.

I also don’t add oil. Once sufficiently processed, the pecans release enough of their own oils to create a creamy spread.

How to use pecan butter

Pecan butter works anywhere you might ordinarily use peanut or almond butter:

• Serve it with apple slices or crunchy vegetable sticks.
• Spread it on gluten-free toast.
• Spoon it over green plantain pancakes or chestnut crepes.
• Add it to cookies, cakes, or other baked treats.
• Blend it into dressings, dipping sauces, or stir-fry sauces.
• Mix it with a more neutral nut butter, such as blanched almond butter, for additional flavor.
• Stir a spoonful into yogurt or porridge.

How to store homemade pecan butter

Transfer the pecan butter to a clean glass jar, cover it, and store it in the refrigerator for up to two weeks.

Because this recipe contains no stabilizers, some natural oil separation may occur. Simply stir it before serving.

Recipes using pecan butter

These are a few recipes where I use my homemade pecan butter:

• Sweet Potato Sheet Cake
• Lectin-Free Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie
• Sugar-Free Sweet Potato Pie
• Healthy Sweet Potato Pecan Pie

More nut butter recipes

For other easy and delicious homemade nut butters, try our Creamy Walnut Butter with Cinnamon, or our delicate and silky Homemade Macadamia Butter.

*This post contains affiliated links, which means I get a small commission if you choose to purchase something via one of my links at no extra cost to you.

Print