Lectin-Free Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie

Did you know you can make a rich and decadent bourbon chocolate pecan pie without corn syrup, grains, gluten, or highly processed ingredients? This lectin-free twist on a Southern classic combines toasted pecans, dark chocolate, and a hint of bourbon in a lightly sweetened filling, all nestled in a grain-free crust. Elegant enough for a holiday table yet simple enough to make any time of year, it delivers the indulgent flavors of the original in a very different kind of pecan pie.

Ditch the corn syrup, keep the pecans, bourbon, and chocolate

Pecans are one of my favorite discoveries since moving to the United States — or, more precisely, to Texas. If you ask me, they are among the tastiest tree nuts. You might already know how much I love homemade pecan butter, but with Thanksgiving approaching, I wanted to use pecans in a lectin-free version of another American classic: chocolate pecan pie.

Traditional pecan pie filling is usually made with a substantial amount of sugar and corn syrup. That creates its characteristic sweetness and sticky texture, but it also makes pecan pie one of the sweetest desserts on the holiday table. Recreating it without those ingredients was not necessarily an easy task, especially since I didn’t want to compensate by using an excessive amount of alternative sweetener.

I’m not saying this version will replace anyone’s grandmother’s traditional pecan pie. But if you want the flavors of pecans, chocolate, and bourbon without the corn syrup and sugar-heavy filling, there is another way to make it.

How to make lectin-free bourbon chocolate pecan pie

I tested this filling twice. My first version was made with sweet potato, coconut cream, egg, and pecan butter. I didn’t add any sweetener because I wanted to see how much natural sweetness those ingredients would provide. It was sweet enough for me, but the coconut cream overpowered the pecan flavor and the filling felt slightly bland.

For the second test, inspired by my sister’s request for a bourbon chocolate pecan pie, I removed the coconut cream and increased the pecan butter. Then I added a splash of bourbon, very dark chocolate, and plenty of roasted pecans in different textures.

Although I originally made the pie without sweetener in the filling, I know that it would not be sweet enough for most people. I now recommend whisking two to four tablespoons of allulose into the eggs. Two tablespoons will create a subtly sweet, dark-chocolate-forward pie, while four tablespoons will make it more recognizably dessert-like.

A note about the lectin-free crust

The grain-free crust is made with almond flour, coconut flour, tapioca starch, butter, egg, and sea salt. It is tender and a little more delicate to handle than a wheat-based pastry, but rolling it between sheets of parchment paper makes transferring it to the pie dish much easier.

How to serve the pie

I make two small pies because we don’t eat large quantities of dessert and prefer not to have too many leftovers. The recipe makes two 5.5-inch (14-centimeter) pies, with four small servings per pie.

Although these dishes are sometimes described as personal-size pie pans, I would not consider an entire pie one serving. The filling is rich and satisfying, so a small slice is usually enough. If you are serving a larger group, the same quantities can be used to make one full-size pie.

For a more classic version, try my Gluten-Free Sweet Potato Pecan Pie.

More Healthy Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes

If you are looking for inspiration on creating a healthy Thanksgiving feast, check out our collection of healthy Thanksgiving desserts that are sugar-free, gluten-free, lectin-free, and nutritious.

*This post contains affiliated links, which means I get a small commission if you choose to purchase something via one of my links, at no extra cost to you.

Print